As a product manager, one of the toughest decisions you'll face is whether to build a product from nothing or buy an existing solution. It's like choosing between baking a cake from scratch or buying one from the bakery—both have their pros and cons. In this article, we'll explore the build vs. buy dilemma to help you make the best decision for your project.

Defining build vs. buy

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, let's clarify what we mean by "build" and "buy." When you choose to build a product, you're opting to develop it internally, either by leveraging your in-house team or by hiring external contractors. On the other hand, buying involves purchasing an existing solution from a third-party vendor, which can range from off-the-shelf software to customizable platforms.

Understanding the build option

When you decide to build a product in-house, you have complete control over every aspect of its development. It's like crafting a masterpiece from raw materials – you can shape it exactly the way you want. Customization is one of the biggest advantages of building your own solution. You can tailor it to fit your unique requirements and make changes as needed along the way.

However, building a product from scratch comes with its fair share of challenges and risks. It requires significant time, resources, and expertise. You'll need a skilled team of developers, designers, and project managers to bring your vision to life. Plus, there's always the risk of delays, cost overruns, and technical issues along the way.

Exploring the buy option

Buying a pre-built solution can save you time and money. It’s convenient and hassle-free. You don't have to worry about the development details because the product is ready to use and out of the box. Plus, many off-the-shelf solutions offer advanced features and functionalities that would take months or even years to develop in-house.

But buying a product also comes with its own set of limitations. You might have to compromise on certain features or customization options to fit the vendor's specifications. Plus, you'll be dependent on the vendor for updates, maintenance, and support, which can sometimes be unreliable.

Build vs. buy: Software

When deciding between buying and building software for a product, several factors come into play. Here's a breakdown:

  1. Buying software: Opting to buy software can be advantageous for product managers looking for quick solutions. It saves time on development and may be cost-effective initially. However, it might lack customization options and could lead to dependency on the vendor.
  2. Building software: Building custom software offers control and tailored solutions to specific needs. Though it may require more time and investment upfront, it provides flexibility and can align precisely with the product's requirements.

Factors to consider

  • Cost analysis: Compare the upfront costs of building with the long-term expenses of buying.
  • Time-to-Market: Consider how quickly you need the product to be ready for launch.
  • Scalability and flexibility: Evaluate the scalability and flexibility of both options to accommodate future growth.
  • Internal expertise: Assess your team's skills and expertise in relation to the project requirements.

Risks of building

Building a product carries inherent risks that need to be carefully assessed. Financial risk is a primary concern, as the project's costs can escalate beyond initial estimates due to unforeseen challenges or scope creep. Technical risk arises from the complexity of development, with the potential for bugs, compatibility issues, and performance bottlenecks. Resource risk stems from the reliance on internal or external talent, as shortages or turnover can derail the project.

Risks of buying

While buying a pre-built solution may seem less risky, it comes with its own set of uncertainties. Vendor reliability is a crucial factor, as you need assurance that the vendor will provide ongoing support and updates to keep the product functional and secure. 

Integration risk arises when the purchased solution needs to be seamlessly integrated with existing systems and processes, which can be complex and time-consuming. Long-term viability is also a concern, as you want to ensure that the vendor will remain in business and continue to support the product for years to come.

Buy vs build analysis

Decision-making process

Making the decision to build or buy requires a systematic approach. Start by gathering information about your requirements, budget, and timeline. Evaluate the available options based on criteria such as cost-effectiveness, scalability, and alignment with your business goals. Consult with key stakeholders, including executives, IT teams, and end-users, to ensure buy-in and alignment across the organization.

Mitigating risks

Regardless of the path you choose, there are steps you can take to mitigate risks along the way. Conduct thorough due diligence on potential vendors or development partners, assessing their track record, reputation, and references. Consider prototyping or conducting proof-of-concept tests to validate the feasibility of your chosen approach before fully committing. Lastly, don't hesitate to negotiate terms and agreements to protect your interests and minimize potential liabilities.

Keep an eye on industry trends and emerging technologies that could influence your decision-making process. For example, the rise of low-code and no-code platforms is enabling companies to build custom solutions with minimal coding knowledge, reducing the barriers to entry for in-house development. Similarly, advancements in artificial intelligence and machine learning are opening up new possibilities for automation and optimization in both build and buy scenarios.

Real-life Experiences

Learning from the experiences of others can provide valuable insights and lessons learned. Seek out success stories and failure stories from peers in your industry or community. Understand what factors contributed to their outcomes and how you can apply those lessons to your own decision-making process.

Impact on quality and innovation

The decision to build or buy can also have a significant impact on the quality and innovation of your product. Building in-house allows for greater control over quality and the potential for groundbreaking innovation. But buying a product can sometimes offer access to cutting-edge technologies and features that would be difficult to replicate internally.

Integration and compatibility considerations are crucial, especially if you're working with existing systems. Make sure the solution you choose can seamlessly integrate with your current infrastructure and support future upgrades and expansions without major disruptions.

User experience and vendor management

User experience should always be a top priority when making product decisions. Consider how customizable each option is and how it will impact the end-user experience. Striking the right balance between standardization and personalization is key to success.

If you decide to buy a product, vendor management and support become critical factors. Choose a vendor that offers reliable support and maintenance services and has a proven track record of delivering quality products and services.

Conclusion

In the build vs. buy debate, there's no one-size-fits-all. The decision is complex and requires careful consideration of various factors, including cost, time, customization, scalability, and risk. By understanding your specific needs, evaluating all options thoroughly, and making an informed decision, you can set your product and your company up for success in

Want insights into the metrics that will propel your business?

Take our PLG Metrics Certified course. Learn to empower individuals, teams, and your organization to redefine their approach to measurement and metric development.

Our course equips you with the tools and strategies needed to create metrics that align with core business objectives, measure team success effectively, and integrate analytics seamlessly into the product development lifecycle.

What are you waiting for? Grab the course now!

Snag the course